The Dispensable King: Why MAGA’s Factions Will Eventually Abandon Trump

The Civil War Brewing Within MAGA: Part 5

Critical Resistance -- Substack

Feb 20, 2025

In our previous installments, we examined the key factions within MAGA—The Christian Nationalists, The Extraction Class, and The Militant Extremists. Now, we turn to the man at the center: Donald Trump. Despite his prominence, Trump is more of a figurehead than the architect of this movement. His role is transactional, and once he is no longer useful, he will be discarded.

Trump perceives himself as the leader of a transformative revolution, but in reality, he is a tool rather than a ruler. His influence rests on the cult of personality he has cultivated, but true power within MAGA lies elsewhere. Project 2025, spearheaded by The Heritage Foundation, is already designing a government framework that does not depend on Trump. While it aligns with MAGA’s broader goals, it underscores the reality that Trump’s presence is not essential. His usefulness is conditional, and once his actions begin to undermine rather than enable their agenda, he will be removed.

To The Extraction Class, Trump is a wrecking ball—effective for tearing down institutions but incapable of governing. Their true priority is a deregulated, AI-driven economy, a vision that does not require Trump’s leadership. The Christian Nationalists tolerate Trump only as long as he advances their theocratic goals, but they do not see him as divinely anointed—merely a convenient tool. The Militant Extremists, obsessed with ideological purity and brute strength, are already growing impatient with Trump’s erratic behavior and perceived compromises. Their loyalty is to their cause, not to him.

Trump’s self-preservation instincts make him an unreliable ally, even to those most loyal to him. When asked in a recent interview whether JD Vance was his chosen successor, Trump refused to endorse him, saying only, “No, but he’s very capable.” Rather than solidifying a successor to carry the movement forward, Trump deliberately left the question open, reinforcing what has always been true—Trump is not building a movement, he is preserving his own power.

But this refusal isn’t just about Trump’s ego; it signals a deeper fracture within MAGA itself. Vance is one of the few figures with backing from both The Christian Nationalists and The Extraction Class, making him a rare unifying figure within the coalition. By refusing to endorse him, Trump is keeping these factions in competition rather than allowing them to consolidate under a single leader. His reluctance to name a successor ensures that MAGA’s internal rivalries continue to escalate, as each faction jockeys for influence in anticipation of a post-Trump era.

(more)

READ MORE: Critical Resistance

Image: Critical Resistance -- Substack